Grand Theft Auto IV Review: 7 Brutally Honest Reasons It’s Still a Masterpiece Today
Key Takeaways
- GTA IV tells a darker, more mature story than most open-world games
- Liberty City feels alive, gritty, and incredibly detailed
- Niko Bellic is one of Rockstar’s best-written protagonists
- Gameplay focuses on realism over arcade-style chaos
- The game still holds up surprisingly well today, despite its age
Grand Theft Auto IV is not just another GTA game—it’s a grounded, emotional crime story set in a gritty version of New York City. With its realistic tone, unforgettable characters, and immersive world, GTA IV remains one of Rockstar’s boldest and most memorable games, even years after release.
Introduction: My First Ride Through Liberty City
I still remember booting up GTA IV for the first time. No flashy explosions. No neon-colored sports cars flying off ramps. Just rain-soaked streets, gray skies, and a tired man stepping off a boat with a heavy accent and even heavier past.
At first, I thought, “Wait… where’s the fun chaos?”
A few hours later, I was completely hooked.
GTA IV isn’t here to make you feel cool. It’s here to make you feel something.
What Is Grand Theft Auto IV All About?
At its core, GTA IV is the story of Niko Bellic, an immigrant chasing the American Dream—or at least trying to survive it.
The Premise in Simple Words
Niko comes to Liberty City believing his cousin Roman lives a life of luxury. Spoiler alert: he doesn’t. What follows is a journey through crime, betrayal, regret, and some very bad life choices.
This isn’t a rags-to-riches fantasy.
It’s more like rags-to-more-complicated-rags.
Liberty City: The Most Realistic GTA Map Ever
Liberty City feels less like a playground and more like a real place.
Why the City Feels Alive
- Pedestrians react naturally to chaos
- NPCs have routines and conversations
- The city has mood—rain, fog, traffic jams
Rockstar nailed the feeling of a crowded, stressful city where everyone is just trying to get by.
Map Comparison With Other GTA Games
| Feature | GTA IV | GTA V | GTA San Andreas |
|---|---|---|---|
| City Realism | Very High | High | Medium |
| Map Size | Medium | Large | Very Large |
| Atmosphere | Dark & Gritty | Cinematic | Playful |
Liberty City might be smaller, but it’s dense. Every block tells a story.
Niko Bellic: A Protagonist With Actual Depth
Let’s be honest—some GTA characters are fun, but forgettable.
Niko? He sticks with you.
Why Niko Works So Well
- He’s haunted by his past
- He questions his own actions
- He doesn’t enjoy violence, but accepts it
I found myself slowing down during missions, actually listening to dialogue. That almost never happens in open-world games.
Gameplay: Slower, Heavier, More Real
GTA IV trades arcade chaos for realism—and that choice divided fans.
Gunplay and Combat
- Enemies react realistically to being shot
- Cover-based shooting feels weighty
- Every fight feels tense
You can’t just sprint in like an action hero. Trust me, I tried. It didn’t end well.
Driving Physics (Love It or Hate It)
Cars feel heavy. They slide. They crash hard.
At first, it feels awkward. Then it clicks—and suddenly every chase feels intense.
Missions: Grounded but Memorable
Also Read This Artcile On 12 Must-Have Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain Mods That Completely Transform the Game
GTA IV missions aren’t about wild stunts. They’re about consequences.
Mission Variety Highlights
- Emotional story-driven missions
- Tough moral choices
- Gritty criminal jobs
Some missions genuinely made me pause and think, “Did I do the right thing?” That’s rare in this genre.
Soundtrack and Atmosphere: Subtle but Powerful
No over-the-top background music here.
What Makes the Audio Special
- Radio stations fit the dark tone
- Realistic ambient city noise
- Strong voice acting across the board
Liberty City sounds tired—and that’s exactly the point.
Strengths and Weaknesses at a Glance
What GTA IV Does Best
- Deep storytelling
- Immersive city design
- Mature themes
Where It Shows Its Age
- Outdated visuals
- Clunky controls at times
- Limited mission variety compared to newer games
Still, the strengths outweigh the flaws.
Is Grand Theft Auto IV Still Worth Playing Today?
Also Read This Article On Spec Ops: The Line Review – 7 Brutal Reasons This War Game Still Hits Hard
Short answer? Yes.
Long answer? If you enjoy story-driven games, slow-burn narratives, and realistic worlds, GTA IV is absolutely worth your time.
Just don’t expect fireworks every five minutes. This game rewards patience.
Final Summary
Grand Theft Auto IV is Rockstar at its most serious, most human, and most daring. It may not be the flashiest GTA game, but it delivers something far more valuable—a story that feels real.
Years later, Liberty City still pulls me back in. Not because it’s fun all the time, but because it feels honest.
FAQs
It depends. GTA IV has a better story and tone, while GTA V offers more freedom and variety.
Around 25–30 hours for the main story, longer if you explore side content.
With patches and settings tweaks, yes. Out of the box, it can be rough.
Yes, but expect a slower pace and darker themes than other GTA games.
